Saturday, May 2, 2015

Videos of the Arrest of Freddie Gray, Mother and Son, State’s Attorney and Police Union: A Lesson in Looking Deeper

We have watched the videos of the arrest of Freddie Gray, the videographer of one, Kevin Moore, later arrested. We have seen the video of the mother beating on her son to get him away from the protest. We have heard Baltimore State’s Attorney Mosby’s announcement of the indictment of six police officers. And more recently we hear the denials by Baltimore Fraternal Order of Police of any wrong doing.
Thanks to David Horsey and the LA Times for the insightful political cartoon
There are human values at work in these videoed incidents viewed nationally and around the world. And perhaps we considered the first response that came into our heads as we watched. 

In the wake of the announcement of the indictment of 6 Baltimore police officers in the Freddie Gray case, the video of the mother forcing her son to leave the demonstration has great positive value, once we hear the interview of mother and son.
Toya Graham, having recently lost her job, says she always tries to show her 16-year-old son, Michael Singlton, what is right. She was seen on footage that went viral forcing him to leave the area of the protests, which later turned violent. Her actions brought debating commentary on the YouTube posting of the footage.
Whatever the opinion, the viewer hears in the interview that human values were at play here, not just a knee-jerk reaction to participation in the aftermath of the violence following the death of Freddie Gray.

We watch with relief as we witness the human values at play in the announcement of indictment following the work of the office of Baltimore’s States Attorney. The announcement yesterday by Baltimore City’s States Attorney Marilyn J. Mosby's that Gray had been illegally arrested and suffered a spinal injury while unrestrained in a police transport wagon led to joyous outbursts in many parts of a city that has been under heavy police and National Guard watch and a 10 p.m. curfew following Monday's rioting.

The police union made public a letter to States Attorney Mosby from Baltimore FOP’s president, Gene Ryan, requesting she appoint an independent prosecutor.
Following the announcement of the indictments, Ryan has decried the State’s Attorney actions are “an egregious rush to judgment.”

And now the report that the arresting officer, Lt. Brian Rice, has had mental health issues adds a new element to the events surrounding Gray’s death. A Business Insider article reports that “Rice, who initially pursued Gray on a Baltimore street when Gray fled after Rice made eye contact April 12th, declared three years ago that he ‘could not continue to go on like this’ and threatened to commit an act that was censored in the public version of a report obtained by the AP from the Carroll County, Maryland, Sheriff's Office.”
Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/indicted-baltimore-police-officers-has-mental-health-issues-2015-5#ixzz3YzSstnnt


There are differing reactions to the videos linked above. We view the video of the arrest of Freddie Gray in horror at the treatment shown, and have deep pain in imagining what happened in that police van as we here the detailed description of the indictment read by States Attorney Mosby.  We see mother and son, Toya and Michael, with varied emotional response—from “You go, Girl!” and “That boy needs to listen to his Mama” to “That kind of video gives  ammunition to those who say we don’t know how to act in public” and “He has a right to protest.”
In these human exchanges—Toya/Michael and Mosby/Police Union—there are differing points of view working against one another that, once  .

What we are witnessing is not a Baltimore thing. It’s an “us” thing. What we are judging as a Black-and-White thing is a human thing.

In these incidents we are struck with our own first reaction to what we see. Rush to judgment? Or perhaps what we have here is a view of the facts with a need to look deeper into the national plague of racial prejudice.